🎉 Up to 70% Off Selected Items
Shop Sale
✕
Cakes
Cupcakes
Cookies
Treats and Bars
Gifts
Corporate
Account
Home
Store
Thanksgiving 2025
Thanksgiving 2025
Filters
Sort:
Latest Arrivals
Price
Min
-
Max
Apply
Collections
Custom Orders
all
Call For Price
Decadent Brownies & Dessert Bars
Baked Goods - Call For Price
Bakery Menu - Order Online!
Cheesecakes, Crumb Cakes, Tres Leches
Custom Cookies, Macarons, and Cakesicles
Decorated Sugar Cookies
Custom Cupcakes/Cake Jars
Bento Box Gift Sets Birthdays & Special Moments | Cakes, Cupcakes, Macarons
Christmas Dessert Menu Order Online Somerville NJ
Easter Menu 2024
Christmas Dessert Menu 2024
Back To School Cookies
French Macarons Menu
Christmas Dessert Menu 2022
Custom Cakes
Corporate Gifting & Catering
Baby Shower Cakes
Sort:
Latest Arrivals
Thanksgiving 2025 | Blue Sheep Bake Shop
-65%
NEW
Quick View
Tres Leches - Holiday
$39.95
$13.98
New
-65%
NEW
Quick View
6" Pumpkin Brownie Cheesecake
$44.95
$15.73
New
-65%
NEW
Quick View
8" Pumpkin Brownie Cheesecake
$59.95
$20.98
New
-65%
NEW
Quick View
Ted The Turkey Cake - Thanksgiving 2025
$59.95
$20.98
New
-65%
NEW
Quick View
Brownie Slab Cake - Thanksgiving 2025
$44.95
$15.73
New
