🎉 Up to 70% Off Selected ItemsShop Sale

Cakes
Cupcakes
Cookies
Treats and Bars
Gifts
Corporate

Cheesecakes, Crumb Cakes, Tres Leches

Cheesecakes, Crumb Cakes, Tres Leches

Price

Min

-

Max

Collections

Custom OrdersallCall For PriceDecadent Brownies & Dessert BarsBaked Goods - Call For PriceBakery Menu - Order Online!Cheesecakes, Crumb Cakes, Tres LechesCustom Cookies, Macarons, and CakesiclesDecorated Sugar CookiesCustom Cupcakes/Cake JarsBento Box Gift Sets Birthdays & Special Moments | Cakes, Cupcakes, MacaronsChristmas Dessert Menu Order Online Somerville NJEaster Menu 2024Christmas Dessert Menu 2024Back To School CookiesFrench Macarons MenuChristmas Dessert Menu 2022Custom CakesCorporate Gifting & CateringBaby Shower Cakes

Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Store Account Cart

© 2026 Blue Sheep Bake Shop. All rights reserved.

Cheesecakes, Crumb Cakes, Tres Leches | Blue Sheep Bake Shop

-65%NEW

Tres Leches - 8" Square Pre-Order

$39.95

$13.98

New

NEW

Cherry Cheesecake - Pre-order

$32.95

New

NEW

Gluten Free Cheesecake (choose your topping) - Pre-order

$27.95

New

NEW

Coffee Crumb Cake - Pre-order

$29.95

New

-65%NEW

Hearts On Fire - 6" Cheesecake

$34.95

$12.23

New

-65%NEW

Oreo Mousse Pie - 8" - Pre-order

$32.95

$11.53

New

-65%NEW

6" Ganache Cheesecake

$22.95

$8.03

New

-65%NEW

Turtle Cheesecake - Pre-order

$29.95

$10.48

New

-65%NEW

Ganache Cheesecake - Pre-order

$29.95

$10.48

New

-65%NEW

8" Cinnabundt Cake

$32.00

$11.20

New

NEW

Italian Rainbow Cookie Cake

$39.95

New

-65%NEW

Raspberry Topped Cheesecake - Pre-order

$39.95

$13.98

New